November 19, 2026
Off Latrobe Road in El Dorado Hills, two gated 55+ neighborhoods share a builder and nearly a name. Both are Lennar communities called Heritage. The original Heritage El Dorado Hills has roughly 1,060 homes, according to the El Dorado Hills Community Services District. The newer Heritage Carson Creek, with its sales office at 720 Violetta Street, is still selling new homes this month.
Downsizers comparing the two usually start with the sticker price. Carson Creek wins that comparison easily. The bills that come every year after closing tell a different story. Each community charges you for having an established neighborhood. At the original Heritage, that cost shows up in a higher purchase price. At Carson Creek, it shows up in higher listed dues and a special assessment.
When this post went to press, Lennar's Heritage Carson Creek page lists a range of $496,990 to $694,342 across 19 available homes. Three collections are open. Roxbury starts at $496,990, Mosaic II at $503,990 and Legends II at $606,342. As of September 2026, the builder's marketing described 12 single-level floorplans of about 1,251 to 2,567 square feet, with two or three bedrooms. Some plans include Lennar's Next Gen suite.
In the original Heritage El Dorado Hills, homes for sale in mid-October 2026 ranged from the low $600,000s to the mid $1 millions. A 55+ community directory based that range on current listings, which numbered 11 at the time. A buyer could get into Carson Creek for roughly $100,000 less than the bottom of that range, and into a new home. The fee schedules move in the other direction.
On its Roxbury and Legends II collection pages, Lennar lists approximate HOA fees of $369 and an approximate property tax rate of 1.03%. The Roxbury page lists approximate special assessment fees of $3,216, and the Legends II page lists $4,572. Those figures are the builder's own approximations.
El Dorado County lists two Community Facilities Districts for Carson Creek Heritage on its Mello-Roos page. The first, CFD 2024-1 for Carson Creek Heritage Village 11, lists roadways, water, drainage, wastewater, parks, trails, landscaping and open space among its purposes. Its fiscal 2024-25 report shows $748,246.69 collected in special taxes for that year. The second, CFD 2024-2, is described as covering ambulance service, and it collected $40,979.03 in fiscal 2024-25.
In the original Heritage, the same directory put HOA dues at about $230 to $258 a month, based on listings in mid-October 2026. It also noted that dues vary by home and by section of the neighborhood.
So the money flows in opposite directions. The newer community asks for less at closing and lists more in recurring charges. The original asks for more at closing and lists lower dues. The longer someone plans to stay, the more the recurring side of that ledger adds up.
This post is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the fees and taxes on any specific home with the right professional before you rely on them.
The original Heritage has had about a decade to develop. The CSD's timeline records a parkland agreement with Lennar dated April 29, 2015, homes under construction in January 2018, and the neighboring public Heritage Village Park opening in summer 2022. The association is the Heritage El Dorado Hills Master Association, which the CSD's directory lists as managed by The Management Trust.
That decade paid for two clubhouses. The first is a 5,000-square-foot building known as The Retreat, with a fitness center, an aerobics and dance studio, locker rooms, meeting rooms, a card room and a catering kitchen. The second, called The Resort, has a pub and kitchen, multipurpose rooms, a theater room, an art room, a billiards room and another card room. Outside, the community has two pools, a whirlpool spa, a barbecue area, tennis, bocce and pickleball courts, walking and biking trails, and a dog park.
Groups listed for the community include a Healthy Lifestyle Club, the Heritage Wheels Car Club and a Coffee Klatch. Listed activities include line dancing, yoga, Zumba, hiking, biking and skiing. The community has no activity director. A buyer at the original Heritage is paying partly for a club calendar that already exists.
The clubhouse was originally planned to open in fall 2025, and by September 2026 the builder's marketing for Heritage Carson Creek was advertising Club Carson as open.
According to 19six, the firm that designed it, Club Carson is about 6,000 square feet. It has a fitness area, a lobby, gathering space, a bar and kitchen, and locker rooms. Outside are a pool and spa, pickleball, tennis and bocce courts, lawns and barbecue picnic areas. By square footage, the building is larger than The Retreat.
The difference is time. The building at Carson Creek is new, and so are the people who use it. On Saturday, Nov. 14, Lennar hosted Gather and Give Thanks at Heritage, a Friendsgiving event for Heritage Carson Creek and its Placer Vineyards community. Builder events like this one tend to set the social calendar in a new community. In an older one, groups like a car club take that role. A Carson Creek buyer who wants a busy calendar may end up helping start it.
This is where the cost difference makes sense. The original Heritage's higher entry price buys an established neighborhood. Carson Creek's lower entry price comes with recurring charges that help pay for neighborhood infrastructure still being built, and with a social life that is still forming.
Both communities rely on Latrobe Road to reach Highway 50 and Town Center. Village Life reported that El Dorado County supervisors approved the final phase of the Latrobe Road and El Dorado Hills Boulevard interchange project. Construction is set to begin in spring 2027 and finish sometime in 2028. This phase rebuilds the eastbound on- and off-ramps and adds a 12-foot path for pedestrians and cyclists, according to the same report. It also changes signals at Latrobe Road and Town Center Boulevard, and at El Dorado Hills Boulevard and Saratoga Way. For a buyer closing this winter, that means a few months of normal driving, then a construction season on the main route to Town Center.
Is Heritage Carson Creek part of the original Heritage El Dorado Hills? They are separate communities with the same builder. The original has its own master association and its own clubhouses, The Retreat and The Resort. Carson Creek is its own gated community built around Club Carson.
Can I still buy a brand-new home in the original Heritage? Homes in the original Heritage come up through resale listings. New Lennar construction for 55+ buyers in El Dorado Hills is at Heritage Carson Creek, where Roxbury, Mosaic II and Legends II are open this month.
Which one is cheaper to own? Carson Creek costs less to buy, and the original lists lower dues. The answer depends on how long you plan to stay and on the fees attached to the home you choose. If you're selling a long-held El Dorado Hills home to fund the move, the price your current home brings can change the math. Our guide to preparing a high-end El Dorado Hills home for sale covers that side.
If you're weighing the two Heritage communities, Sac Platinum Realty can pull the tax bill, the dues and the recent sales for the specific homes on your list. We'll put the purchase price and the recurring costs side by side so you can see both before you decide. If your move also means selling the home you're in now, we can plan both sides together, starting with a home valuation. Let's Talk.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Real Estate
Real Estate
Real Estate